Extraction of Benzoic Acid
EXTRACTION OF BENZOIC ACID
By: Berry Begg
Abstract:
The experimental goal and purpose for this experiment was to use the primary extraction techniques to separate benzoic acid from a mixture containing cellulose, a natural polymer of glucose, and methyl orange. A new technique utilized during this experiment was extraction. The overall results were skewed because of error during the lab like not allowing the crystals to properly dry.
Introduction:
This experiment required the extraction of benzoic acid from a mixture of cellulose and methyl orange and in order to do so various methods were utilized. The first method used before extraction was the steam bath. In this experiment the steam bath was used to heat the low boiling point liquid of crude benzoic acid and 50ml of diethyl ether. Extraction is defined as the separation of compounds based on differences in polarity and solubility. A compound is polar if a difference in EN values within a molecule creates partial charges and creates a net dipole of polar bonds. A compound is soluble based on the rule that “like dissolves like,” for example polar solvents dissolve polar molecules. Liquids that have different polarities can either be miscible or immiscible. Miscible liquids dissolve in one another, while immiscible liquids simply form layers on top of each other and do not dissolve. Whether two liquids are miscible depends on their polarities and intermolecular forces, not on their densities; when two liquids are immiscible, density only decides which layer sits on top. The three different types of extractions learned this week included, solid-liquid extraction, liquid-liquid extraction, and acid-base extraction. Solid-liquid extraction is when a solvent is added to a mixture and is separated by filtration. This type of extraction was used in this lab through vacuum filtration. This extraction was very helpful in this experiment because it separated the liquid and solid in the most accurate way, therefore leaving us with accurate data. Liquid-liquid extraction is the separation of 2 liquids of opposing polarity that are immiscible in each other. Acid-base extraction is very alike to liquid-liquid extraction; however, this extraction method purifies acids and bases from the mixture. This type of extraction was also used in the lab to separate the aqueous NaOH layer, which holds the sodium benzoate, from the ether layer, using a separatory funnel.

Editor’s note, November 16, 2026: Several statements in this report have been corrected in place. Whether two liquids mix depends on polarity, not density; density only decides which layer is on top. NaOH converts benzoic acid into sodium benzoate, which moves into the aqueous layer, while the diethyl ether remains the organic layer. Methyl orange is an ionic sodium salt that dissolves in the aqueous layer, which is why that layer was orange and then turned pink when HCl was added; the original text said it stayed in the organic layer. The 49.12% is a mass recovery of the crude mixture, not a percent yield or a percent composition. The benzoic acid crystals came from acidifying the benzoate solution with HCl, with the ice bath lowering their solubility, not from cooling a heated solution. The Experimental section describes two NaOH extractions while the Discussion says the process was done three times; both are left as written because the original record does not settle which is correct. The chemical table image is reproduced as originally posted, but several of its entries are not reliable: the 4.01 g is the crude mixture rather than pure benzoic acid, diethyl ether’s density is about 0.71 g/mL and benzoic acid’s about 1.27 g/mL, and 30 mL of 1 M NaOH and 50 mL of 6 M HCl are 0.030 mol and 0.30 mol. The recorded masses (4.01 g and 1.97 g) are unchanged. In the Experimental section, the clause “and the mixture was placed in a separatory funnel” was removed from the filtration sentence as an error: the vacuum filtration, not a separatory funnel, removed the insoluble material. Section headings, a short explanation of the acid-base extraction in this lab, and a safety note have been added. No new experimental data were introduced.
Procedure: dissolving, filtering, and extracting with NaOH
Experimental:
4.01 grams of crude benzoic acid mixture was weighed on a watch glass and then placed into a 125 mL Erlenmeyer flask. Afterwards, 50 mL of diethyl ether was also added into the same 125 mL Erlenmeyer flask along with a few boiling stones to prevent bumps from arising. This mixture was then placed on top of a steam bath until it began to boil. Diethyl ether is extremely flammable (flash point about -45 °C) and can form explosive peroxides on storage, so it should be heated only on a steam bath with no open flames nearby, preferably in a fume hood, and the separatory funnel should be vented often to release ether vapor pressure. The 1 M NaOH and 6 M HCl are corrosive, so goggles and gloves are needed. Immediately after boiling, the vacuum filtration method was used to remove the insoluble material from the mixture. We then transferred the filtrate (ether) into a 500 mL separatory funnel and added 30 mL of 1M NaOH. After allowing the mixture to sit for a couple minutes, we could see the layers separate. When the mixture was totally separated, the bottom aqueous solution was drained into a 250 mL flask and the NaOH process was again repeated with the ether solution to get the remainder of the aqueous solution drained. The aqueous solution in the 250 mL flask was then placed in a bucket of ice. 50mL of 6M HCl was then added to this aqueous solution, which immediately turned it a bright pink, which showed that the acid indicator methyl orange was working. After this, we again used the vacuum filtration method to separate the crystals, the solid precipitate. The crystals were collected and separated. They were not allowed the time to properly dry, which could have presented error.
Results: mass recovered from the crude mixture
Results:
The experiment began with 4.01 grams of crude benzoic acid mixture, which was subjected to an extraction. After the extraction process in a separatory funnel, vacuum filtration, only 1.97 grams of the mixture remained. The mass significantly dropped during this process because the mixture went through purification by the removal of cellulose and methyl orange. According to the data, the percent mass recovery comparing the original and final data can be calculated by:
Percent mass recovery = (grams of recovered solid (final)/grams of crude mix (original)) x 100%
= (1.97/4.01) x 100%= 49.12%
This 49.12% is a mass recovery, not a percent yield: no reaction makes benzoic acid in this experiment, and the report does not say how much of the 4.01 g crude mixture was benzoic acid, so the share of the benzoic acid that was recovered cannot be calculated. Because the crystals were not fully dry, the 1.97 g probably also includes some water, which would make the recovery read high. (Rounded to two decimal places, 1.97/4.01 is 49.13%.)
Before the last extraction, with the addition of HCl, the solution turned into very neon pink, however after a couple purifying processes, the separation of the benzoic acid crystals was successful but due to the fact that the crystals could not properly dry and a lot of the crystals stuck to the filter paper, therefore the results may be skewed.
Discussion: layers, colors, and recovering the benzoic acid
Discussion:
After the crude benzoic acid mixture was added to the 50mL of diethyl ether, it took about 15 minutes to boil on the steam bath. The mixture in this flask was a dark brown color, however after using the Buchner funnel filtration process, the dark brown cellulose remained in the filter paper. This separation occurred because the cellulose was insoluble in the diethyl ether, therefore created the mixture to separate. After the addition of 1M NaOH to the filtered benzoic acid mixture, there was immediately a clear separation of the layers. This occurred because the two solutions were immiscible due to their difference in polarity; the difference in density decides which layer is on the bottom, and the aqueous layer sank because diethyl ether (about 0.71 g/mL) is less dense than water.

After this separation, the bottom aqueous layer was orange, while the top organic layer was nearly clear. The benzoate ion in this case is highly polar so it can interact with the hydrogen from the water molecules. The methyl orange in this case is a sodium sulfonate salt, so it is ionic and dissolves in the aqueous layer rather than the ether, which is why the bottom aqueous layer was orange. Once we had completely removed and separated the aqueous layer, NaOH was once again added to complete any separation that may not have occurred the first time. Some benzoic acid can still remain in the organic layer after one extraction, and repeating the addition of NaOH and extracting the aqueous layer each time can minimize this. This process was done three times in this experiment to ensure correct data. After the solute had been separated and the aqueous layer was placed on ice, 6M HCl turned the solution pink and white solid began to form in the solution.

This solution turned pink after the addition of HCl because a main property of methyl orange is that it is an acid/base indicator and since the methyl orange had dissolved in the aqueous solution along with the sodium benzoate, the strong acid turned the indicator from its yellow-orange basic form to its pink-red acidic form. Following this, after another vacuum filtration, the creamy colored HBz solid remained in the filter paper. During the filtration, not all of the pink was filtered out, even after three processes of doing it, which may have contributed to the percent error. The solid HBz in this case was an indicator that some methyl orange still remained, so it was not entirely pure.
Finally, the benzoic acid crystals came from acidification, not from cooling a heated solution: the 6 M HCl re-protonated the benzoate ion back to neutral benzoic acid (HBz), which is only slightly soluble in water, so it came out of solution as a white solid. Temperature played a supporting role, because keeping the aqueous solution on ice lowered the solubility of benzoic acid further, so more of it precipitated before the vacuum filtration. In conclusion, through solid-liquid, liquid-liquid, and acid-base extractions, benzoic acid was isolated from the original mixture due to differences in solubility, polarity, and acid-base behavior in this experiment.
Why NaOH and HCl move benzoic acid between the layers in this lab
Benzoic acid has a pKa of about 4.2. In the ether solution it is a neutral molecule, but shaking it with 1 M NaOH, which is far more basic than pH 4.2, removes its acidic proton and converts it to sodium benzoate (Figure 2 above). As an ionic salt, sodium benzoate is much more soluble in water than in diethyl ether, so it moves into the lower aqueous layer. The cellulose had already been removed as an ether-insoluble solid in the first filtration.
Methyl orange is already a sodium salt, so it also ends up in the aqueous layer instead of staying in the ether. Above about pH 4.4 it is yellow-orange, which matches the orange aqueous layer. Adding HCl reverses the first step. The 50 mL of 6 M HCl (about 0.30 mol) is far more acid than the 30 mL portions of 1 M NaOH (0.030 mol each), so the solution becomes strongly acidic, the benzoate ion is re-protonated to neutral benzoic acid (Figure 3), and the benzoic acid precipitates. Below about pH 3.1 methyl orange turns red, which is the pink color seen when the acid was added. The indicator stays dissolved in the acidic water, so pink left on the filtered solid is trapped indicator rather than benzoic acid. Checking the dried solid’s melting point against pure benzoic acid’s 122 °C shows how clean it is, and the same acid-base logic is used to separate the drugs in an acid-base extraction of an analgesic tablet.
References:
Padias, A. (2007). Making the Connections: A How-To Guide for Organic Chemistry Lab Techniques. (1 ed.). Hayden-McNeil Publishing;.
[…] leaves it behind with the binder. For another worked extraction with NaOH and then HCl, see Extraction of Benzoic Acid; for caffeine pulled into DCM, see Isolation of Caffeine from Tea […]
[…] other extraction labs on Odinity, see the extraction of benzoic acid from a mixture with cellulose and methyl orange, separating acids and neutral compounds by solvent extraction, and the acid–base extraction of an […]